A Caribbean itinerary isn’t built by simply adding up islands. It’s built around whether or not you cross a break in scale: the one that separates hops of a few miles from crossings of ninety.
This break in scale determines everything. Seven days stay on one side of it, ten days cross it, fourteen cross it twice. Here are the three formats, with the published distances and what actually lengthens them.
- Saint-Martin – Anguilla5 – 8 nautical milesday hop
- Saint-Martin – Saint-Barth12 – 15 nautical miles16 – 18 by the actual route
- Saint-Martin – Antigua93 – 95 nautical milesone overnight passage
- Antigua – Guadeloupe40 – 45 nautical mileshalf a day
An arc, two scales of distance
The Northern Caribbean islands don’t form a regular chain. They form a tight cluster and a leap.
Within the tight cluster, the distances are negligible. Anguilla lies five to eight nautical miles from Saint-Martin. Saint-Barthélemy is twelve to fifteen miles away in a straight line, and more like sixteen to eighteen by the route actually sailed, since you round the island’s eastern point and exit the Simpson Bay lagoon. At twenty-five knots, a captain can have the yacht in Gustavia in about forty minutes.
Then comes the break. Saint-Martin to Antigua is ninety-three to ninety-five miles of open water, one of the classic trade-wind crossings in the Caribbean, commonly sailed overnight.
The entire structure of an itinerary comes down to this asymmetry: either you stay on the right side of the leap, or you commit to it.
Seven days — the triangle, with no overnight passage
This is the natural format for the area, and the most comfortable.
Saint-Martin serves as the technical base: provisioning, crew, services. Anguilla brings beaches and deserted cays, just a handful of miles away. Saint-Barthélemy brings Gustavia and fine dining. Three distinct registers, no overnight passages, and days where sailing time adds up to less than an hour.
This format lends itself to long days ashore or at anchor rather than long days underway. That’s its appeal, and why it suits groups looking for unhurried time in one place.
This is the rule we apply. The three islands fall under three different administrations, and Saint-Martin alone counts as two. Each entry consumes office time, during office hours. Three changes are workable; four turn the week into an administrative circuit.
Ten days — adding Antigua, and one overnight passage
Three extra days don’t go toward adding another island to the triangle: they go toward crossing the leap.
The ninety-three to ninety-five mile crossing to Antigua is sailed overnight, carried by the trade wind. You wake up in an entirely different register: English Harbour, Nelson’s Dockyard — a UNESCO World Heritage Site — Falmouth with its berths for larger yachts, and Nonsuch Bay on the east coast, a vast stretch of water protected by the reef, approached from the south, with no provisioning ashore.
This format changes the nature of the trip. You move from a triangle of short days to a port-hopping passage with a genuine crossing in the middle. It calls for a vessel and a group comfortable with a night at sea — a point where hull type and range matter more than length, as detailed in our explorer vs. motor yacht comparison.
Fourteen days — heading down to Guadeloupe
The second leap is shorter than the first. From Antigua to Guadeloupe, the distance is forty to forty-five miles — forty-three miles from Falmouth to Deshaies according to one passage-time table, or about seven hours at six knots under sail, considerably less for a motor yacht.
So it’s half a day’s sailing, not a crossing. However, rounding the southern point to reach Pointe-à-Pitre lengthens the route noticeably: some routing sources put the full detour at more than eighty miles.
Three of our fleet’s yachts also list the Grenadines within their winter cruising ground, alongside Saint-Martin and Antigua. This is the other possible extension of a longer format, further south along the arc. We don’t publish a distance for this leg: we don’t have a reliable measurement for it.
The three outlines, day by day
What follows is an outline, not a fixed program. It shows how the constraints fit into a week; the captain will reorder it according to the day’s trade wind and available slots.
Seven days. Embarkation in Saint-Martin, inside the lagoon if the yacht’s size allows, otherwise in the outer bay. A first day devoted to Anguilla, departing early to catch the mooring-buoy window, returning to Road Bay or the French side for the night. A second day on Anguilla’s cays. Then the crossing to Saint-Barthélemy, with mandatory clearance in Gustavia. A full day on site. Return to Saint-Martin and a final evening in Grand Case, the island’s most sought-after bay. Disembarkation on day seven.
Ten days. The same outline for the first four days, then the overnight crossing to Antigua. Three to four days there are enough to cover English Harbour, Falmouth, and Nonsuch Bay on the east coast, with a day trip to Barbuda if weather allows. Disembarkation in Antigua rather than a return leg: that’s what makes this format efficient, and it means flights need to be arranged accordingly.
Fourteen days. The previous format, extended by the run down to Guadeloupe — forty to forty-five miles, half a day. Two to three days there, then either a return north to Antigua for disembarkation, or a local disembarkation. It’s the only format that leaves unhurried time after crossing the break in scale twice.
One principle applies to all three: embarking and disembarking in two different islands frees up a full day compared with a round trip. It costs more in flight logistics, and it’s almost always the right trade-off beyond seven days.
What lengthens an itinerary without lengthening the distance
Miles aren’t the limiting factor in this area. Three constraints consume more time than the sailing itself.
The Simpson Bay bridge opening windows. The lagoon only opens at fixed times, and in one direction at a time. Entering and leaving on the same day requires two compatible windows. A yacht with a beam over seventeen meters can’t enter at all.
Anguilla’s daytime mooring buoys. The marine park’s mooring fields are in use from 6 a.m. to 7 p.m. So a day in Anguilla isn’t an overnight stop, it’s an excursion: you arrive early, leave before 7 p.m., and the yacht spends the night at Road Bay or back on the French side.
Formalities at every border. A cruising permit in Anguilla, mandatory clearance in Gustavia — the only port of entry on Saint-Barthélemy — and two checkpoints in Saint-Martin. Arriving in late afternoon in front of a closed office costs a full day.
The practical consequence is that a Caribbean itinerary is built around office hours and mooring-buoy windows, not a calculation of miles. Our Caribbean destinations pages detail these constraints island by island.
Distances, and why they should be checked against the chart
Published sources diverge, sometimes significantly, depending on whether they measure a straight line between two reference points, a port-to-port route, or a multi-stop itinerary. We have discarded several values clearly calculated from the wrong reference points. A real itinerary is planned on the chart with the captain, who factors in rounding headlands, sea state, and the day’s trade wind direction.
This is also why we don’t publish crossing times in hours for motor yachts: it depends on the chosen cruising speed, and the same route can be covered in four hours or nine, depending on that choice.
Which yacht for which format
The format determines the size of yacht more than the other way around.
Over seven days, a more maneuverable yacht is more useful than a larger one. You need to be able to use a daytime mooring buoy and then return to sleep, and to pass through the bridge if you want the lagoon. MANATEA, twenty-nine meters and the only yacht in our fleet based year-round in the Caribbean, is positioned exactly for this logic, with charters offered departing from all three islands.
Over ten or fourteen days, the overnight crossing and Falmouth’s berths change the equation: larger yachts regain the advantage. RILASSATA, forty-nine meters, offers Caribbean availability from December to February and a range of four thousand nautical miles. ANNA I at sixty-seven meters and ST. DAVID at sixty meters list the Caribbean, Saint-Martin, Antigua, and the Grenadines within their winter cruising ground.
The full selection is available on our yachts available for charter.
Frequently asked questions
How many miles separate Saint-Martin from Antigua?
Ninety-three to ninety-five nautical miles of open water, according to published sources. It is one of the classic trade-wind crossings in the Caribbean, commonly sailed overnight. It also marks the area’s break in scale: everything else in the Northern triangle is measured in tens of miles at most.
Can you visit the three Northern islands without sailing at night?
Yes, that’s precisely the appeal of the seven-day format. Anguilla is five to eight miles from Saint-Martin, Saint-Barthélemy twelve to fifteen miles direct and sixteen to eighteen by the actual route. None of these legs requires an overnight passage.
What does a fourteen-day format allow for?
Crossing the break in scale twice: an overnight passage to Antigua, then half a day to Guadeloupe, forty to forty-five miles away. Three of our fleet’s yachts also list the Grenadines, another possible extension further south.
What actually lengthens a Caribbean itinerary?
Not the miles. The Simpson Bay bridge opening windows, Anguilla’s mooring buoys being for daytime use only, and formalities at every change of jurisdiction. Arriving at a closed office costs a full day, whereas an inter-island leg costs an hour.
Can online published distances be trusted?
With caution. Sources diverge depending on whether they measure a straight line between two reference points, a port-to-port route, or a multi-stop itinerary, and several figures in circulation are clearly calculated from the wrong reference points. The figures on this page are orders of magnitude; an itinerary is planned on the chart with the captain.
Choose the format before choosing the islands
The order of decisions matters. You don’t start by picking a list of islands and then a duration: you decide whether you’re willing to sail overnight, which sets the format, then build around bridge schedules, daytime mooring buoys, and customs offices.
Give us your duration, your dates, and the number of guests: we’ll come back with an itinerary built around the real constraints and the yachts that can deliver it.
Plan a Caribbean itinerary
Seven days with no overnight passage, ten with one crossing, fourteen with two. We build the format before proposing the islands.





